Skip to content

HMRC – Preferential financial recovery in insolvencies, but at what cost….

Analysis has found that HMRC has received an extra £14.4 million in tax owing from insolvencies since it regained its ‘preferential creditor’ status in December 2000.

The preferred status enables HMRC to be paid from a formal insolvency process ahead of unsecured creditors, which is effectively the general body of suppliers to that business. Given the forbearance from HMRC during Covid, the level of HMRC debt we often see with insolvency matters is significant, meaning asset realisations will need to be significantly greater to enable a return to the general body of suppliers.

In many instances, there will be no financial return at the bottom end and the best suppliers can hope for, if they don’t have bad debt insurance, is VAT bad debt relief on the sum not payable.

In our opinion, the preferential position HMRC find themselves in has the following consequences:

  • Some banks reducing the amounts they can lend to business and increasing the interest rates they offer on business loans.
  • Banks looking to mitigate exposure by way of invoicing discounting facilities, fixing their debt against the sales ledger. This is more costly than “normal” bank lending products, squeezing margins and reducing HMRC gain from corporation tax recoveries going forward from a viable business.  
  • Banks even more so, looking for personal guarantees from directors for business borrowings because if the ship goes down, they want a life raft to jump on to.  

In the overall scheme of things, the sum received through preferential status since December 2000 is not substantial for HMRC and we have no doubt that these funds would be far better off in the pockets of unsecured creditors as a whole. Indeed, it would be more beneficial if HMRC’s preferential status was abolished altogether, as it was in 2003, which, in turn, will allow greater lending opportunities for companies to recover, potentially avoiding a formal insolvency process while also increasing future tax receipts.

If you need any advice or assistance on any insolvency-related issue, then please contact PBC Business Recovery & Insolvency on 01604 212150 (Northampton), 01908 488653 (Milton Keynes) or email to enquiries@pbcbusinessrecovery.co.uk. Alternatively, visit www.pbcbusinessrecovery.co.uk for further information.